For many shippers, the tender is the most important date in freight procurement. This is where you decide, for a year or less, which forwarders run your lanes and at what prices. Yet in many companies the tender still runs through Excel and email and drags on for weeks.
In this article, you will learn how a transport tender works step by step, where most of the time is lost and what to watch for in each phase.
What is a tender in logistics?
A tender is a call for bids, usually for one mode of transport (sea, air, truck, rail), with which a shipper awards a whole transport volume for a fixed period.
Forwarders bid fixed prices for given lanes, usually with tiers by weight, pallet spaces or loading metres. Unlike spot tendering, it is not about a single transport, but about planning security for many recurring transports.
Tender management means the planning, execution and evaluation of such tenders, usually supported by software. The term bid management is also used with the same meaning.
Step 1: Create the data basis
Every tender is only as good as the data it is based on. Before you invite forwarders, you need a complete overview of your transports over the last twelve months:
- Origin and destination of every shipment, at least at postcode level
- Type of shipment: general cargo, part load or full truckload
- Weight, number of pallets or loading metres
- Frequency per week or month
- Previous costs per lane
The data usually comes from the TMS, from the ERP or from the forwarders' invoices. Allow enough time for this step. Missing or contradictory data is the most common reason why a tender stalls later.
Practical tip: A freight cost analysis shows which lanes cause the largest part of your costs. With an ABC analysis, you sort the lanes by their share of the volume. This tells you where a tender pays off most and which rare transports are better placed in spot tendering.
Step 2: Define scope and goals
Define what is being tendered and what you want to achieve. Typical questions:
- Which lanes and modes of transport belong in the tender?
- For what period should the prices apply?
- Is it mainly about costs, about capacity or about the number of service providers?
- Which requirements apply to all bidders, for example ADR, temperature control or certain time windows?
Record the goals in writing. Later they decide which quote fits best.
Step 3: Specify the rate structure
This is where it is decided whether you can compare the quotes quickly later. Specify a fixed rate structure: which lanes, which tiers, which units and which surcharges. This also includes the question of whether, for example, tolls and fuel surcharge are included in the price or stated separately.
If you leave the structure open, you receive quotes in different formats. Then you convert surcharges by hand, and every conversion is a possible source of error and costs you time and nerves.
Step 4: Select and invite the forwarders
Invite your existing forwarders and add new bidders in a targeted way for lanes where you want more competition. What matters is that only the invited forwarders see your tender. Your volumes and lanes are trade secrets. You can read more about the difference under open and closed tender.
With the invitation, tell the bidders everything they need for a reliable quote: schedule, data basis, requirements and the criteria by which you award. You can also specify whether you require NDAs or whether the invited forwarder wants to take part at all. All of this avoids follow-up questions and lost time.
Step 5: Support the bidding phase
While the forwarders calculate, questions come in. Answer them centrally and in such a way that all bidders receive the same information. Check incoming quotes early for completeness and plausibility. A missing price or a typo of one digit easily goes unnoticed in a large table and only becomes expensive once the transport has run.
Example with made-up figures: A tender with 120 lanes and five weight tiers comprises 600 prices per bidder. With ten bidders, that is 6,000 individual prices that you have to check and compare.
Step 6: Evaluate and compare scenarios
Now you compare the quotes. The lowest price per lane is only one view. Run through several award scenarios, for example:
- every lane to the cheapest bidder
- a maximum of three forwarders in total
- prefer incumbent forwarders when the price gap is small
Include performance as well as price. Logistics KPIs such as on-time rate or damage rate show whether a cheap forwarder also runs reliably. Often the first evaluation is followed by a second round in which you ask selected bidders for an improved quote.
Step 7: Award, document and implement
Inform the forwarders of the result, including those who did not win. Transfer the new prices to your TMS and document the award completely: who bid what, how the decision was made and why. You need this documentation for queries from purchasing, controlling or audit, and as a basis for the next tender.
Or even better: Use a solution that takes over most of the tasks for you automatically. This saves time, nerves and money.
How long does a tender take?
That depends on the scope and above all on how much manual work is involved in the process. In many companies, what costs the most time is not the decision, but collecting, standardising and checking the quotes after a tender ends. A rough time plan for a tender with Excel and email:
| Phase | What happens | Typical time wasters |
|---|---|---|
| Preparation | Data basis, scope, rate structure | Missing or contradictory data |
| Bidding phase | Invitation, questions, quotes | Follow-up questions by email, different formats |
| Evaluation | Comparison, scenarios, second round | Merging and checking tables |
| Award | Decision, information, implementation | Transferring prices, documentation |
Typical mistakes in a tender
Starting without a clean data basis. Forwarders calculate with a safety margin when volumes or shipment structure are unclear.
Not specifying a structure. Every quote looks different, and the comparison becomes tedious, time-consuming manual work.
Putting too much into the tender. Lanes that are rarely run make the tender hard to follow, but hardly bring better prices.
Looking only at the price. A forwarder that is cheap but unreliable ends up expensive.
Checklist for your next tender
- Is the transport data of the last twelve months complete?
- Are scope, period and goals set down in writing?
- Is the rate structure, including surcharges, specified?
- Do only the invited forwarders see your tender?
- Are quotes checked for plausibility as soon as they arrive?
- Have you defined criteria for quality in addition to price?
- Is the award fully documented?
Tender management with eFrexx
With eFrexx, you specify the rate structure, with as many lanes and tiered prices as you like. You upload your tender data and the previous year's tender as a file. Every entry is checked for plausibility immediately, for the shipper and for the bidders. You calculate award scenarios directly in the system, and several rounds are possible. Our customers shorten their tender cycles by up to 70%. Read more on the tender management page.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a tender and a call for bids? Call for bids is the umbrella term for any structured request for prices. A tender is a call for bids for a whole transport volume over a fixed period, usually a year or less. A single, short-term transport, by contrast, is awarded through spot tendering.
How often should you run a transport tender? Most shippers tender their volume once a year. In strongly fluctuating markets or with new sites, a shorter period can make sense. What matters is that enough time remains between tenders to observe the forwarders' performance.
How many forwarders should you invite to a tender? There is no fixed number. For each lane, enough bidders should take part for real competition to arise. At the same time, every bidder increases the effort for comparison and checking if the quotes are not automatically comparable.
What do you need for a tender in logistics? You need a clean data basis of your transports, a fixed rate structure, a list of suitable forwarders and clear criteria for the award. Software for tender management helps to make quotes comparable and to document the process.